Every maintained piece retains its own dated history. Entries are newest first; a publication change does not move the underlying evidence cutoff unless the record says so.
Replaced the twenty summary-reference pages after direct human review found them non-useful; partitioned the three omnibus visual experiences into thirty-three substantive top-level source sections, rendered their original DOM and design at stable routes, and made audience pages compose those exact isolated fragments.
Addressable research parts and richer audience routes.
Decomposed the three large visual experiences into twenty canonical research parts with stable pages, source coordinates, bounded answers, nonclaims, related parts, entity links, audience backlinks, and a structured registry; rebuilt all six audience pages as explicit compositions with role-specific proof standards, working outputs, sequenced parts, decision checks, focused analysis, and named evidence.
Human visual correction.
Replaced the first evidence-plot candidate's Arial/Helvetica fallback stack, compressed heavy display treatment, and dominant red with IBM Plex typography, lighter proposition hierarchy, blue-green thesis color, restrained ochre signals, and a calm dark decision panel after direct human review found the released candidate loud and retro.
Evidence-plot visual system.
Replaced the cream, serif, card-led publication template with a subject-specific plotting surface: a claim-context trace on the landing page, narrow proposition typography, flat route indexes, evidence matrices, responsive recomposition, and a shared visual register across public, source-document, entity, and backstage pages.
Public information architecture.
Separated three reader-facing experiences from four backstage planning artifacts; replaced the file-type menu with six audience routes, deep-linked exploration, and sixteen structured benchmark and system pages; retained legacy redirects and removed embedded editorial histories from public experiences.
Retired repeated generic B91 retrieval after three bounded lawful passes over six named surfaces: the content ledger remains six full, twenty abstract or official, one access-blocked and unassessed, and zero complete AI lifecycles; four exact new-custody conditions can reopen the row.
Added the InfoViP actor and closed-opportunity boundary: the closed Elsa/API/UI opportunity names three research mentors but no selection or execution, official profiles preserve bounded research roles, a fellow cannot perform inherently governmental functions, and service operation, maintenance, QA execution, release approval, authorization, and the InfoViP-Elsa join remain unassigned.
Repaired the InfoViP 2024-2026 episode chain: a seemingly 2026 future-tense FDA page is explicitly content-current to 2024, a 2026 FDA biography names a current project lead without operations authority, and the Elsa 4.0/HALO launch contains no InfoViP-specific integration; the correction strengthens chronology and relationships without changing 15 named cases or zero complete episodes.
Upgraded InfoViP to a self-reported approved and production-integrated component: the final CIOMS report adds AWS/AERS integration, more than 30 million historical and about 8,000 daily submissions, bounded routine case-series use, and monitoring while retaining an absent QA plan, planned audits, incomplete routine roles, uninvestigated downstream effects, current no-ATO counterevidence, and zero complete episodes; a 2026 Elsa/API/UI opportunity is prospective.
Upgraded InfoViP to one counted field-evaluation and operating-pipeline near-miss: 20 unique reviewers made 58 submissions, a later primary abstract reports operation over 29 million historic plus daily reports, and three FDA awards total $2.40 million obligated and $2.86 million estimated; current routine use, acceptance/ATO, outcome, return, whole cost, ROI, and complete episodes remain unresolved.
Added InfoViP as the fifteenth named AI-assisted practice or afterlife case: seven-evaluator co-design now joins an operational pilot, 28-million-report plus incoming processing, and a later human-in-the-loop performance report while the current inventory still says development, implementation N/A, and no ATO; complete episodes remain zero.
Recovered B92's exact publisher abstract as a bounded non-AI multicriteria, Monte Carlo, and rank-stability method comparator; the 27-row ledger is now six full texts, twenty abstract or official-content rows, one unassessed B91 row, and zero complete AI lifecycles.
Audited B110's live-build lineage: the live DiscoverWater page differs from the sole published page state, eight of twelve dependency names occur in pinned source, two of three sampled assets match canonically, and zero exact-build or audience-outcome receipts were added.
Rechecked the final three content-unassessed A208 DOI rows: B110 gained an official abstract, pinned framework and application source, and one current same-named public interface; at that pass B92 and B91 remained unassessed, and no exact live-build join, use denominator, audience outcome, recheck, or AI lifecycle was admitted.
Investigated all fourteen residual A208 DOI rows: eleven now have substantive primary content including one full chapter, three remain metadata-only, one evaluation-to-redesign mechanism and two practice-context near misses were added, and zero complete AI lifecycles were admitted.
Investigated nine high-signal A208 DOI rows and added eight substantive primary abstract or official-project surfaces, seven explicit human evaluations, one AI-adjacent non-GenAI production-intent near-miss, fourteen remaining content-unassessed DOI rows, and zero complete lifecycles.
Resolved A208's eight stable non-DOI keys into three DOI repairs, two year corrections, one rejected foreign PMID, four full texts, one gated primary text, one non-AI embedded-use comparator, and zero complete AI lifecycles.
Recovered five exact full texts from A208's 27 no-abstract DOI rows: four empirical papers separate controlled audience measurement, public-sector co-design/demo, and enterprise production intent, while zero reaches accepted deployment plus later affected-audience recheck and 22 DOI rows remain unassessed.
Screened 114 exact DOI records from A208's authoritative stable frame: 87 expose abstracts, only the already-known GPT paper carries an explicit GenAI cue, 86 abstract nonmatches remain unexcluded, and AIDSVu supplies one mature non-AI visualization afterlife but zero complete AI lifecycles.
Screened the 122 authoritative A208 stable-key titles for explicit GenAI cues: one GPT course study exposes one pinned 1,271-blob output bundle, zero audience-delivery or later-recheck chains, and 121 title nonmatches that remain not surfaced rather than excluded.
Added Lexara as a two-week longitudinal development-decision near-miss and combined it with ten reader cases and three production afterlives: 14 named cases, one direct controlled reader effect, one longitudinal evaluation, and zero full twelve-receipt exact-artifact decision/recheck episodes.
Completed A208's six-domain stable-key crosswalk: 127 supplement positions yield 122 distinct review-owned keys, five exact-looking DOI candidates remain outside the authoritative frame, one printed PMID resolves to another paper, and lifecycle screening remains unstarted.
Crosswalked A208's first complete domain: eleven printed Education labels plus the B59 overlay yield twelve authoritative bibliography/DOI keys; M. Lu (2020) has no A208 bibliography record, so its plausible Crossref candidate remains unadmitted and the lifecycle count remains null.
Reconstructed A208's missing Education identity as Hernández-Calderón et al. (2023), DOI 10.1093/iwc/iwac043, through the review's post-selection category paragraph and bibliography; retained the published question mark, absent publisher correction, unfinished stable-key crosswalk, and null lifecycle count.
Separated A208's reported count from its auditable inventory: the supplement's domain totals reach 127, but it identifies 126 citations and one literal question-mark Education row; inventory repair now precedes lifecycle screening and the qualifying count remains unknown.
Added a 127-study decision-visualization review as a coverage map, kept its explicit non-GenAI and longitudinal limits, and left the qualifying same-artifact lifecycle count unknown rather than reporting zero of 127.
Added conditional retry survival as a distinct cost-evidence layer: VisCoder2-32B and GPT-4.1 both finish at 732 of 888 execution passes after 584 versus 714 revisions, while missing comparable debug-resource telemetry and accepted outcomes keep the ledger at 0/12 accepted-cost comparisons and no route winner.
Added an actor-separated production recovery-state row: three held dashboard afterlives, two maintainer-verified restorations, zero affected-actor recoveries, zero authority transfers, and zero complete twelve-state cases.
Separated human evaluation by AI role and artifact lineage: one of ten held rows directly carries selected AI-generated charts into an independent controlled-reader effect, five measure adjacent human outcomes, and zero reaches accepted delivery plus later same-lineage reader recheck.
Separated available governance controls from governed deployment: three provider control contracts, two named-feature organizational-use reports, and two adjacent governance-process studies remain distinct; zero of seven held rows clears the nine-receipt same-deployment join.
Separated public acquisition from adoption for twelve named data-visualization skill listings: the rows collapse to ten parent repositories and eleven documented lineages; all twelve carry install signals while zero exposes public invocation, retention, organizational acceptance, or outcome receipts.
Added an eleven-stage information-and-authority anatomy from six primary authoring or analysis systems: all six separate generation, execution, and some critique route, four expose meaningful human control, and zero reaches accepted delivery, intended-reader outcome, or later maintenance.
Added the bounded capability-to-practice bridge audit: ten primary cases yield three controlled partial joins to analyst use, analyst correction, or reader harm, while zero reaches exact-version accepted delivery or a complete reader, later-maintenance, and whole-cost episode.
Added Selective TTS as the strongest fixed-budget near miss and audited its pinned implementation: one of eleven held fragments matches a declared partial call/output-token budget, while zero joins equivalent observed route-wide use to frozen accepted outcomes; ledger v6 keeps the three receipt levels separate.
Added a six-receipt exact release-validation audit across Graphy, MAIDR-AI, Prism, OpenClaw, KubeStellar, PM4Py-UCM, and DV-World; every receipt appears somewhere, zero of seven clears the same-lineage join, and the null remains scoped to named surfaces.
Added Graphy as a distinct longitudinal co-design lane: the same three blind co-designers completed 12 sessions across four workshops and eight months while selected changes were implemented; no formal efficacy result, workshop-version binding, tagged release, representative recheck, or complete lifecycle episode was added.
Added ChartAgent's same-task accuracy/tool-call sweeps as a partial cost proxy; ledger v5 finds zero of nine held fragments with equivalent route-wide cost plus a frozen accepted-artifact denominator and retains every failure state without selecting a winner.
Pinned MAIDR's later AI study to a dedicated legacy study surface and v2.10.0 version floor; retained the exact participant-tested build and model as unknown, counted nine selected later maintenance and deprecation events, found zero representative rechecks, and treated the TypeScript rewrite as a separate validation target.
Audited four promising horizontal lifecycle joins and admitted zero new episodes; added representative pre-AI MAIDR accessibility evidence, preserved the current AI-enabled rewrite as a separate artifact state, and quarantined a described-but-removed human study.
Added a five-threat configuration-validity card and two direct human/model chart studies; benchmark results stay in their task-and-grader lanes and the current qualifying Vizier configuration-run count remains zero.
Added adjacent ProMCP profiling and a commit-pinned release audit; ledger v4 now preserves cold start, discovery, execution phase, effective topology and runtime state without claiming a visualization comparison, reproduced run, or cost winner.
Added partial second-person change in Prism and OpenClaw, Prism's repeat contributor, and OpenClaw's open repair proposal; separated accepted change, repeat contribution, maintenance authority, and independent recovery without moving the lifecycle comparison to complete.
Added Prism as a third same-artifact dashboard afterlife and the first held multi-attempt delivery chain; separated report, repair, corrected release, maintainer recheck, and independent recheck while keeping whole cost and lifecycle comparison open.
Added METAL as a seventh specialist-cost fragment and separated matched rounds from equal resources: its paper/code audit found different call topologies and missing per-arm usage; ledger v3 now requires planned and observed receipts over twelve dimensions, with no run or cost winner.
Expanded the specialist total-workflow cost protocol after a sixth peer-reviewed fragment exposed preparation-versus-inference accounting but failed four internal receipt checks: exact figures remain quarantined, the ledger now has eleven lanes and five cost classes, and no route or winner exists.
Added one self-reported same-dashboard production-afterlife chain from KubeStellar and one measured refinement-effort record from PM4Py-UCM; kept whole cost, comparison, handoff, accessible-reader use, decisions, and trust explicitly missing.
Added a protocol-only specialist total-workflow cost ledger: five primary evidence fragments, ten explicit lanes from task acceptance through reader use and maintenance, ten unfulfilled release gates, no summed total, and no route winner.
Added a design-only longitudinal learning protocol: three instruction arms, five creator waves through six-month unassisted transfer, a separate blinded reader stage, ten outcome lanes, ten unfulfilled release gates, zero contacts, and no learning or atrophy result.
Added ViviDoc's typed State-Render-Transition-Constraint result and its authoring, reader, delivery, maintenance, and autonomy boundaries; classified it as pre-freeze evidence captured after freeze and left all seven forecasts unresolved and unchanged.
Prepared the blank R4 editor-calibration request: ten stimulus-by-lens baselines, ten synthetic quality vignettes with two swapped repeats, three response states, fourteen rejected adverse records, no editor or calibration result, zero calls, and Q8 still open.
Added the R4 first-call decision register: seven attributable receipts across five gate categories, exactly 30 primary calls with a separate retry cap, exact-set release, twenty admissible paths, sixteen rejected adverse states, all real receipts pending, zero calls, and Q8 still open.
Froze the R4 response contract: two lens-specific prompts, two fail-closed schemas, three honest response states, twelve rejected aggregate/lens/identity/evidence/state failures, five remaining first-call gates, zero calls or results, and Q8 still open.
Materialized the five R4 inputs: five opaque hashed SVGs, a 19-file model-input allowlist with nine source-evidence files, five evaluator-only defect records, nine origin bindings, adverse leakage/hash checks, corrected visual-inspection findings, zero calls or results, and Q8 still open.
Added the blocked R4 integrity/readability preregistration: five candidate contexts, three empty exact-model slots, two separate lenses, human-editor and tie-rule gates, zero results or calls, and Q8 still open.
Added the E0 tier-separated scorer: two mechanical tiers, six named nonmechanical lanes, 15 synthetic ledgers, 90 preserved not-run states, exact authority binding, aggregate score/pass rejection, zero calls, and no actual artifact or human result.
Added the E0 owner/provider decision register: six exact gates, 17 admissible paths, four authority roles, secret-field and wrong-role rejection, a separate final release, zero selections, zero calls, and no inferred provider or owner approval.
Added the E0 acceptance-authority candidate: five fixture-specific role maps, six nonmechanical outcome lanes, 30 explicit mechanical-pilot not-run states, fail-closed human-authority checks, zero calls or contacts, and research-owner scope selection still pending.
Added the corrected E0 one-layer intervention decision packet: one post-artifact evidence-reconciliation mechanism, one insertion, one silent-divergence target, five evaluator-only mappings, eight bundle exclusions, a fail-closed overall-pass rule, zero calls, and explicit Vizier-owner ratification still pending.
Added the credential-free E0 artifact runner: five source checks, 15 isolated fixture-arm envelopes, model-input versus evaluator-only custody, editorial answer-key redaction, external artifact/render/trace/check hashing, fail-closed receipt identity, six remaining blockers, zero model calls, and no spend.
Added the E0 current-harness manifest preflight: five locked packet hashes, local toolchain and available-skill observations, three arm roles, one 18-field equivalent-receipt schema, seven named blockers, zero model calls, and no spend authority.
Added the fifth of five E0 source packets: two first-party synthetic data versions, canonical application state, ten exact states, seven isolated trajectories, stale-selection recovery, history, export, keyboard, narrow-delivery, and prepared-change contracts; application, maintenance, accessibility, and human evidence remain unrun.
Added the fourth of five E0 source packets: exact official 2024 ACS estimates and margins of error, all pairwise comparisons, a misleading strict-rank revision, refusal and render receipts, and an expert-review gate; baseline and human evidence remain unrun.
Added the third of five E0 source packets: a first-party synthetic governed-BI model with exact measures, vintage, roles, verified queries, refusals, and a $16,830-versus-$7,730 fanout incident; production and human evidence remain unrun.
Added the second of five E0 source packets: exact CC0 Palmer Penguins data, pooled-versus-within-species checks, preserved revision branches, equivalent receipts, and a familiar-data no-efficacy boundary.
Added the shared-baseline readiness gate: historical custody is reconciled, one of five context slots is executable, and architecture comparison waits for rights-clear packets and equivalent receipts.
Initial public edition integrating the research synthesis, shared capability timeline, benchmark evidence, technique comparisons, demonstrated negatives, and research gaps.
Added the B91 retrieval stop: one access-blocked row remains content-unassessed in the unchanged 6/20/1/0 ledger, zero generic B91 targets remain active, and exact new lawful custody is required before another search pass.
Added the InfoViP research-contact and operating-authority boundary: three named mentors can receive research questions, but the closed opportunity supplies no selection, work, acceptance, or release receipt, a nonemployee cannot supply governmental approval, and operation, maintenance, QA execution, release approval, authorization, completed audit, and the application join remain open.
Added the InfoViP date and role correction: visible source dating moves an apparently 2026 future-tense page back to 2024, a current FDA biography supplies a project lead but no operations or maintenance authority, and the Elsa 4.0/HALO release does not establish an InfoViP application join.
Added the final InfoViP component receipt and QA boundary: approval, AWS/AERS integration, more than 30 million historical and about 8,000 daily submissions, bounded case-series human control, and monitoring now sit beside the absent QA plan, planned audits, incomplete routine roles, uninvestigated signal effects, current no-ATO record, and a prospective 2026 Elsa/API/UI change trigger.
Added InfoViP's denominator-bearing six-month real-work evaluation, later operating-scale deduplication evidence, and a bounded three-award envelope: 20 unique reviewers, 58 submissions, 29 million historic plus daily reports, $2.40 million obligated, and $2.86 million estimated, while preserving the missing accepted whole-platform build, current routine use, ATO, outcome, return, whole cost, and ROI.
Followed InfoViP from seven-evaluator co-design through an operational pilot, at-scale incoming-report processing, a performance and human-quality-control report, and current governance counterevidence; admitted one operational near-miss, not accepted deployment, routine use, outcome, recheck, cost, or a complete episode.
Recovered B92's exact publisher abstract and exposed its uncertainty-and-ranking mechanism for practice while preserving the missing human sample, AI role, release, delivery, use, outcome, recheck, and cost; B91 remains the sole content-unassessed DOI row.
Tested B110's public source lineage rather than assuming it: the live page does not match the sole published page state, partial data-asset lineage remains, and no exact build, audience-use, outcome, accessibility, cost, or AI receipt was recovered.
Added B110 as a bounded non-AI public-delivery afterlife: an official abstract, immutable source states, and a current DiscoverWater interface reduced the residual content gap to two at that pass while preserving the missing build join, acceptance, use, audience outcome, recheck, and whole cost.
Reduced the residual A208 DOI content gap from fourteen to three: one full chapter binds three UX experts and twenty-five problems to a third version, while two practice-context cases remain below accepted deployment, outcome, and recheck.
Added seven explicit human-evaluation receipts from eight new substantive A208 DOI content surfaces; InfoViP remains an NLP and unsupervised-learning production-intent near-miss because installation, accepted release, routine use, outcome, later change, and evaluator return are unconfirmed.
Added the cancer diary as a bounded non-AI field-use comparator: system logs report increasing use and an independent review recovers an 11-clinician QUIS median of 4.38, while accepted build, consequential outcome, later event, and affected-clinician recheck remain missing.
Added a three-lane primary human-evidence boundary from five recovered A208 full texts: controlled task evidence, public-sector co-design/demo, and enterprise production intent remain distinct, with zero accepted deployments and 22 DOI rows plus eight non-DOI keys still unassessed.
Added AIDSVu as a mature non-AI delivery and afterlife comparator: a ten-year paper, current data release, annual update rules, broad use receipts, and explicit maintenance boundaries still supply no AI role, immutable AI artifact, audience consequence, calibrated trust, or affected-audience recheck.
Added one artifact-custody boundary from the authoritative A208 frame: a pinned 1,271-blob GPT output bundle improves prompt/output/code custody but adds no immutable provider snapshot, versioned release, intended-audience delivery, outcome, or later recheck.
Added Lexara's six-developer, two-week field-deployed evaluation as longitudinal development-decision evidence while keeping immutable build, accepted downstream delivery, consequential audience decision, calibrated trust, whole cost, and post-release recheck explicitly unjoined.
Added the complete 127-position review register: 122 distinct A208 keys, five unadmitted external DOI candidates, one quarantined identifier conflict, no duplicate authoritative keys, and no lifecycle result because screening has not started.
Added the 13-row Education stable-key crosswalk: twelve identities have A208 bibliography/DOI keys, while M. Lu (2020) remains a supplement-only authority gap with a plausible but unadmitted registry candidate.
Added the source-preserving B59 repair overlay: A208 uniquely reconstructs the Education question mark as Hernández-Calderón et al. (2023), while the publisher file remains uncorrected and the full stable-key crosswalk and lifecycle count remain unfinished.
Added the review inventory-integrity gate: A208 reports 127 studies, but its published appendix names 126 citations and leaves one Education row unresolved; no complete screen begins by guessing or scoring that placeholder.
Added a review-lineage boundary: a 127-study decision-visualization review establishes broad coverage but does not construct a complete same-artifact GenAI lifecycle denominator; the qualifying count remains unknown, not zero.
Consolidated three production afterlives into a twelve-state actor-separated decision card: two reach accepted repair, corrected delivery, and maintainer recheck; zero reaches affected-actor recovery, authority transfer, or a complete row.
Added an eight-receipt reader-outcome delivery boundary: one direct controlled AI-created-chart reader effect, five adjacent human-outcome rows under different AI roles, three creator or co-design rows, one model-reader-only row, and zero accepted-delivery or later-recheck chains.
Added a three-rung capability-to-human bridge: HAIChart reaches controlled analyst use, interactive task decomposition reaches analyst correction, and ChartAttack reaches reader harm; none of ten audited cases reaches exact-version accepted delivery or a complete episode.
Added the fixed-budget practitioner boundary: Selective TTS matches declared partial call/output-token budgets but omits repair and failed-worker cost and counts candidates, so creators now get separate declared, observed, and accepted-work receipts; the complete result is zero of eleven.
Audited seven leading lifecycle cases against repeated representative use, immutable tested build, exact exposure model, versioned release, later event, and post-change recheck; zero clears all six, and the public decision tool preserves each partial cell and reopen condition.
Separated repeated co-design from release afterlife: Graphy adds three returning blind co-designers, 12 sessions, four workshops, eight months, implemented interaction changes, and seven public commits, but no workshop-version binding, formal efficacy result, release, or representative recheck.
Separated per-attempt averages from cost per accepted artifact: all attempts and failures stay in route cost, only contract-passing outputs enter the denominator, and the held result remains zero of nine complete comparisons.
Added MAIDR's source-custodied legacy AI-study surface, v2.10.0 version floor, abstract-level findings for eight blind and low-vision participants, nine selected maintenance and deprecation events, zero representative rechecks, and a separate TypeScript rewrite boundary.
Added a seven-key horizontal admission rule and four rejected near-misses: representative pre-AI MAIDR use does not validate the current AI-enabled rewrite, and a described-but-removed public-health human study is not a trust or usability result.
Added a four-state handoff ladder: accepted second-person change in Prism and OpenClaw, repeat contribution in Prism, maintenance authority still missing, and independent recovery still missing; corrected OpenClaw from no repair to one open, unmerged proposal.
Added Prism as the third same-artifact dashboard afterlife and the first held multi-attempt delivery chain: successive non-owner failures reach v1.8.11 and maintainer runtime verification, but not independent final acceptance, whole cost, handoff, accessibility, decision, or trust.
Added OpenClaw Agent Dashboard as the second same-artifact afterlife and the first here with a non-owner operator-reported later failure; separated release, installed use, misleading zero, acknowledgement, repair, corrected release, and recheck with a six-field admission card while keeping lifecycle completeness open.
Added the first self-reported same-artifact production afterlife in custody: KubeStellar Console through live regression, two-step repair, restored deployment, and a new prevention check; translated the remaining whole-cost, handoff, accessibility, decision, trust, comparison, and transfer gaps for six audience routes.
Added current repair and evolution benchmark evidence, audited its evaluators, and separated prepared change tests from observed production maintenance and whole cost.
Added longitudinal governance-visualization evidence and a lifecycle acceptance ledger translated for practitioners, leaders, editors, researchers, product teams, and accessibility work.
Initial public edition mapping practitioner jobs, tool choices, creator experience, delivery failures, reader reactions, and open evidence gaps.
Added accepted external AI-assisted work in Prism and OpenClaw, Prism's repeat contributor, and OpenClaw's open repair proposal; production efficiency, governance, and maintenance remains 1 of 4 because maintenance authority and independent recovery remain absent.
Added Prism's multi-attempt delivery chain through corrected release and maintainer runtime verification; production efficiency, governance, and maintenance remains 1 of 4 because independent final acceptance, comparison, whole cost, handoff, and reader outcomes are missing.
Added OpenClaw Agent Dashboard's independent operator-reported unresolved cost-display failure as a second afterlife case; observer diversity improves, but production efficiency, governance, and maintenance remains 1 of 4 without repair, recheck, whole cost, handoff, or reader outcomes.
Added KubeStellar's same-dashboard production-afterlife case and PM4Py-UCM's measured refinement record while preserving production efficiency, governance, and maintenance at 1 of 4 because no complete lifecycle, comparison, or reader outcome exists.
Added the first forecast calibration check: one visible pre-freeze source omission, seven not-due forecasts, zero resolutions, and no rewritten probabilities, confidence values, or maturity scores.
Initial public edition defining the ideal state, present scorecards, historical reconstruction, contextual endpoints, and forecast movements with direct evidence links.
Translated the B91 stop rule across seven audience routes: three bounded searches justify pausing repeated work, not classifying the paper; one access-blocked row stays unassessed, four exact triggers can reopen it, and sponsors redirect effort when no new custody is available.
Translated the InfoViP actor-and-authority boundary across seven audience routes: route research questions to three named mentors, keep five operating-authority roles separate and unassigned, retain the nonemployee governmental-functions limit, and treat the closed opportunity as administrative status rather than completed or shipped work.
Translated the repaired InfoViP chronology and application boundary across seven audience routes: verify exact object, event date, role, and application join; do not use search recency as chronology, project lead as operations authority, or the Elsa 4.0/HALO launch as an InfoViP integration receipt.
Translated the final InfoViP production and QA answer across seven audience routes: component approval, AWS/AERS integration, more than 30 million historical and about 8,000 daily submissions, bounded case-series control, absent QA plan, planned audits, incomplete roles, uninvestigated downstream effects, current no-ATO counterevidence, and a prospective Elsa/API/UI change trigger remain one maintained truth.
Translated one InfoViP field-use, operating, cost, and governance answer across seven audience routes: 20 real-work evaluation users, a later 29-million-history plus daily operating pipeline, and a $2.40 million obligated / $2.86 million estimated award envelope stay beside implementation N/A, no ATO, zero whole-cost or ROI receipts, and zero complete episodes.
Translated one InfoViP operational-governance answer across seven audience routes: preserve both the 28-million-report plus incoming process and current development/no-ATO inventory, with 15 named cases and zero complete episodes.
Translated one B92 publisher-abstract recovery across seven audience routes: practice gets a rank-stability mechanism, each operational route keeps its missing receipts, the current ledger is 6/20/1/0, and no layer promotes method description into human use or impact.
Translated one B110 source-lineage answer across seven audience routes: one live page, zero exact public builds, eight of twelve matching dependency names, two of three canonical asset matches, and zero audience outcomes.
Translated one public-delivery afterlife across seven audience routes: B110 had gained an official abstract, pinned source artifacts, and one current live named interface; at that pass B92 and B91 remained unassessed, and no route promoted reachability into continuous use, adoption, outcome, or AI efficacy.
Translated the residual DOI result across seven audience routes: fourteen investigated, eleven substantive, one full chapter, three metadata-only, one evaluation-to-redesign mechanism, two practice-context near misses, and zero complete AI lifecycles.
Translated one prototype-evaluation result across seven audience routes: eight substantive surfaces, seven explicit human evaluations, InfoViP's prospective production intent, fourteen remaining content-unassessed DOI rows, and zero complete production lifecycles.
Translated one field-use result across seven audience routes: three DOI repairs and one non-AI embedded-use comparator, with the gated primary text, missing AI lifecycle receipts, and unknown complete-review denominator preserved in every layer.
Translated one primary-evidence ladder across seven audience routes: five recovered full texts add four empirical cases and three pre-deployment receipt lanes, while zero accepted deployments, 22 unassessed DOI rows, and eight non-DOI keys remain explicit.
Translated one mature-platform boundary across seven audience routes: 114 DOI records and 87 abstracts surface one non-AI afterlife comparator and zero complete AI lifecycles, while 86 abstract nonmatches remain unexcluded and no route may borrow AIDSVu's delivery receipts into an AI claim.
Translated one artifact-custody result across seven routes: 122 titles triaged, one explicit GPT signal, one pinned supplemental-output bundle, zero audience-delivery or later-recheck chains, and 121 nonmatches that remain unexcluded.
Translated one exact-artifact decision/recheck result across seven routes: Lexara adds a longitudinal development-decision near-miss, while zero of 14 named reader, production, and evaluation cases reaches accepted downstream delivery, audience consequence, calibrated trust, whole cost, and post-release return.
Translated one 122-of-127 review result across seven routes: every route preserves five unresolved authority joins, one conflicted identifier, unstarted screening, and a null lifecycle count while changing the decision language and useful layer.
Translated one 12-of-13 Education result across seven routes: every route separates source label, authoritative review key, external candidate, evidence, and admission authority, and none may promote topical fit into provenance or a lifecycle count.
Translated one source-preserving repair across seven routes: the supplement still prints a question mark, A208 uniquely reconstructs Hernández-Calderón et al. (2023), and no route may call the overlay a publisher correction or a complete lifecycle denominator.
Translated one review inventory result across seven routes: 127 studies reported, 126 appendix citations identified, one Education row unresolved, and the complete GenAI lifecycle count still unknown.
Translated the review-lineage boundary across seven audience routes while preserving one shared result: 127 studies map the adjacent field, but the complete same-artifact GenAI lifecycle denominator is unknown and no route may report zero of 127.
Translated the conditional retry result across seven audience routes while preserving one shared answer: both routes reach 732 of 888 execution passes after 584 versus 714 revisions, but missing comparable resources and contract acceptance leave total cost and the route winner unknown.
Translated the production recovery boundary across seven audience routes while preserving one shared result: three afterlives, two restorations, zero affected-actor recoveries, zero authority transfers, and zero complete twelve-state rows.
Translated the reader-outcome boundary across seven audience routes while preserving one shared result: one direct controlled AI-created-chart effect, five adjacent human-outcome rows, and zero complete delivered-reader recheck chains.
Translated the governance boundary across seven audience routes while preserving one shared result: three provider control contracts, two named-feature use reports, two adjacent governance processes, and zero complete same-deployment joins.
Translated the public-acquisition boundary across seven audience routes: each keeps twelve named install signals separate from the zero-of-twelve public invocation, retention, organizational-acceptance, and outcome rows, without implying audience use or private absence.
Translated the eleven-stage system anatomy across seven audience routes: each keeps the same 6/6 technical-loop, 4/6 human-control, and 0/6 downstream-chain result while changing the decision question without implying an architecture winner or audience use.
Translated the capability-to-practice bridge across seven audience routes: each keeps the same three controlled partial bridges, zero accepted-delivery bridges, zero complete episodes, and the first missing receipt without implying audience use.
Translated the fixed-budget result across seven audience routes: each keeps matched declared partial budget, observed route-wide use, and contract-accepted output cost separate; one of eleven held fragments supplies the first receipt and zero supplies the latter two.
Translated the bounded zero-of-seven release-validation result across seven audience routes: each asks for the same six receipts, retains the named-surface limit, and targets the first exact-release return-user check rather than another disconnected stage.
Translated Graphy's longitudinal co-design result across seven audience routes: every layer retains the same three returning co-designers and eight-month design record while keeping formal efficacy, workshop-version binding, release, representative recheck, adoption, and whole cost visibly missing.
Translated the accepted-cost denominator across seven audience routes: practice, BI, research, journalism, product, learning/access, and sponsors all retain one route-wide numerator and one frozen contract-passing denominator; zero of nine held fragments supplies both.
Translated the MAIDR version-floor boundary across seven routes: study surface, first containing release, participant-tested build, later maintenance, representative recheck, and rewrite remain separate states, with zero new complete lifecycle episodes.
Translated one lifecycle-admission result across all seven audience routes: exact artifact and version, release, later event, actor, custody, and outcome remain one join; four candidates produced zero new episodes.
Translated one configuration-validity result across all seven audience routes: each gets a decision-language question and layer while benchmark lift remains forbidden and no configuration winner exists.
Added phase and topology language to practitioner, BI, research, and builder layers: cold start, discovery, execution phase, effective topology and runtime state now stay beside planned and observed totals, while hidden work remains missing.
Added the four-state handoff rule for all audience layers: accepted change, repeat contribution, maintenance authority, and independent recovery remain distinct; Prism reaches the first two and OpenClaw reaches the first plus an open repair proposal.
Added a five-receipt recovery rule for practitioner, BI, research, newsroom, product, and access routes: keep report, repair, corrected release, maintainer recheck, and independent recheck distinct; Prism is missing the final receipt.
Added a planned-versus-observed resource receipt to practitioner, BI, research, and product routes; matched rounds, candidate counts, rates, nominal caps, and model labels no longer count as equal budget.
Added a Fabric context-envelope and correction receipt from two C-grade first-party RSS captures: declare report/model traversal, permissions, semantic inclusion, acceptance state, failure reproduction, repair, regression, ownership, and cost without inferring a bug, breach, efficacy, prevalence, demand, or reader use.
Expanded the practitioner clock and BI procurement scorecard so total cost begins at route preparation, separates five cost classes through reader delivery, declares volume and amortization, and rejects source telemetry whose denominator does not reconcile.
Added a retained-human-value check from independent newsletter and Portuguese practice evidence: purpose, collaboration, creative friction, audience context, inspectable correction, feedback, and delivery.
Added an audience-language evidence ladder separating source wording, qualified discovery, decision-path use, and changed work, with stronger accessibility and search-measurement boundaries.
Initial public edition mapping audiences, decision products, useful routes, publication gates, and evidence of actual use.
Turned the final content gap into a stop-and-reopen decision.
B91 stays access-blocked and content-unassessed in the unchanged `6 / 20 / 1 / 0` ledger. After three bounded passes, generic search is paused until exact new lawful custody appears; effort can move to a stronger lifecycle-bearing target without manufacturing a negative row.
Mapped InfoViP's research contacts without inventing an operating owner.
The closed Elsa/API/UI opportunity names three research mentors but no selection or execution; their official profiles support research and project roles, while operation, maintenance, QA execution, release approval, authorization, and the application join remain unassigned.
Repaired InfoViP's 2024–2026 episode dates and relationships.
An apparently 2026 future-tense FDA page is explicitly content-current to 2024, so it does not contradict the 2025 component report. A 2026 FDA biography adds a current project lead without operations authority; the Elsa 4.0/HALO launch adds no InfoViP-specific integration. The correction changes the decision trace, not the 15 named / 0 complete count.
Final InfoViP evidence upgrades the component, not the whole lifecycle.
A final CIOMS report says the deduplication component was approved, installed in AWS, integrated with AERS, and processing more than 30 million historical plus about 8,000 daily submissions. The same report keeps the QA plan, completed audits, routine roles, and downstream effects open; the current inventory still records implementation N/A and no ATO. A 2026 Elsa/API/UI opportunity is a prospective recheck trigger. The audit remains 15 named cases and zero complete episodes.
InfoViP adds counted field use and a bounded award envelope, not a complete lifecycle.
Twenty unique reviewers made 58 submissions in a six-month internal real-work evaluation; a later primary abstract reports a 29-million-history plus daily operating pipeline; three related FDA awards total $2.40 million obligated and $2.86 million estimated. Current implementation/ATO, routine post-release use, outcome, return, and whole cost remain unresolved; 15 named cases still yield zero complete episodes.
InfoViP adds an operational pipeline, not a complete deployment.
Joined seven-evaluator co-design to an operational pilot, 28-million-report plus incoming-report processing, a human-in-the-loop performance report, and current governance counterevidence. The audit now contains 15 named cases and zero complete episodes.
One publisher abstract reduced the content gap to one.
B92 adds an abstract-level non-AI uncertainty-and-ranking method, not a human-use or delivery lifecycle. The current ledger is 6 full / 20 abstract or official / 1 unassessed / 0 complete AI lifecycles; B91 remains unassessed.
Public source matched partially, not as a deployed build.
The live DiscoverWater page differs from the sole published page state; two of three sampled data assets match canonically. No exact-build, audience-use, outcome, accessibility, whole-cost, or AI receipt was added.
One public-delivery afterlife reduced the gap to two.
B110 gained an official abstract, pinned primary source, and a same-named live KU interface. At that pass B92 and B91 remained unassessed; no exact live-build join, use denominator, audience outcome, recheck, whole cost, or AI role was added.
Residual DOI content gap reduced to three.
Investigated all 14 residual rows, recovered substantive content for eleven including one full chapter, and retained three metadata-only rows. Added an expert evaluation-to-redesign mechanism and two practice-context near misses without admitting a new AI lifecycle.
Seven evaluations kept below deployment.
Eight new substantive primary abstract or official-project surfaces add seven human studies and one InfoViP production-intent near-miss, but no confirmed installation, accepted release, outcome, or later recheck. Fourteen DOI rows remain content-unassessed.
A field-use receipt kept below AI lifecycle.
Repaired the eight-key non-DOI stratum and added one non-AI embedded-use/usability comparator without promoting it to an accepted AI release, outcome, or later audience recheck.
Human evidence kept below deployment.
Five recovered full texts add four empirical pre-deployment cases across controlled task, public-sector co-design/demo, and enterprise production-intent lanes. None reaches accepted field release plus later affected-audience recheck; 22 DOI rows and eight non-DOI keys remain unassessed.
Mature delivery kept separate from AI efficacy.
AIDSVu adds ten years of public delivery, aggregate use, governance, and a later data release to the review screen, but no AI role or version-bound affected- audience recheck. It remains a non-AI comparator; 86 abstract cue nonmatches remain unexcluded.
One explicit GPT title among 122 authoritative A208 keys leads to a pinned one-commit output bundle, but no versioned release, delivered intended audience, outcome, or later recheck. The 121 title nonmatches remain unscreened, so the complete denominator stays unknown.
Development selection kept below audience impact.
Lexara adds a two-week field-deployed evaluation near-miss with six developers, 38 experiments, 57 newly authored cases, ten models, and six prompts. Across 14 named reader, production, and evaluation cases, zero joins immutable build, accepted delivery, consequential decision or calibrated trust, whole cost, and later same-lineage recheck.
Full review frame stops at 122 of 127 authoritative keys.
Five exact-looking DOI identities lack review-controlled joins, one printed PMID points to another paper, and lifecycle screening remains unstarted. The executive boundary keeps identity confidence, identifier validity, and admission authority separate.
Education key audit finds one unresolved authority join.
Eleven printed labels plus B59 yield twelve A208 DOI keys. `M. Lu (2020)` has a plausible Crossref candidate but no A208 bibliography record, so the executive boundary reports 12 of 13 authoritative Education keys and keeps lifecycle screening unstarted.
Missing review row repaired without upgrading the denominator.
A208's article uniquely reconstructs the Education `?` as Hernández-Calderón et al. (2023), DOI `10.1093/iwc/iwac043`. The executive boundary preserves the published source value, repair provenance, absent publisher correction, unfinished stable-key crosswalk, and null lifecycle count as separate states.
Reported review count separated from row identity.
A208's appendix preserves 127 domain rows but names 126 citations and one unresolved Education entry. The executive gate now requires inventory repair before a complete primary-paper screen; neither the count nor the unknown lifecycle result is silently rewritten.
Review corpus kept below lifecycle denominator.
A five-database review establishes breadth across 127 decision-visualization studies, but its non-GenAI focus and unjoined lifecycle fields keep the qualifying count unknown rather than zero of 127.
Retry topology kept below accepted cost.
Across 888 tasks, VisCoder2-32B and GPT-4.1 both finish at 732 execution passes after 584 versus 714 revisions. Missing comparable resource telemetry and contract acceptance keep the result out of cost and route-selection claims; the held total is now 0/12 accepted-cost comparisons.
Production recovery kept actor-separated.
Three held dashboard afterlives yield two maintainer-verified restorations, zero affected-actor recoveries, zero authority transfers, and zero complete twelve-state cases; the next valid gate is a return user or exercised second- person authority.
Human evaluation split by AI role.
Added the bounded ten-row reader-outcome result: one direct controlled AI-created-chart effect, five adjacent human-outcome rows, three creator/co-design rows, one model- reader-only row, and zero complete delivered-reader recheck chains.
Governance claims now require one deployment row.
Three provider control contracts, two named-feature organizational-use reports, and two adjacent governance processes are retained as distinct evidence; zero of seven clears the complete nine-receipt join.
Public acquisition is now below adoption.
Twelve named skill listings collapse to ten parent repositories and eleven documented lineages. All twelve carry install signals; zero exposes public invocation, retention, organizational acceptance, or outcome receipts. Popularity can prioritize inspection, not authorize procurement or efficacy claims.
System anatomy now assigns authority.
Across six primary authoring or analysis systems, generation-execution-critique coverage is 6/6, meaningful human control is 4/6, and accepted-delivery, intended-reader, and maintenance chains are 0/6. The result supports an eleven-stage custody map, not one universal agent topology.
Three controlled bridges stop before delivery.
Ten primary cases yield three partial technical-to-human joins, zero exact-version accepted-delivery joins, and zero complete reader/later-maintenance/whole-cost episodes. The result narrows the capability-to-practice gap without claiming ordinary field efficacy.
Fixed-budget result kept below total cost.
Selective TTS adds a matched declared partial call/output-token budget, while a pinned code audit keeps repair, failed-work, input/image/local compute, people, and acceptance visibly missing. The accepted-cost result is now 0/11 with no route winner.
Accepted cost needs a route numerator and pass denominator.
Added ChartAgent's same-task accuracy/tool-call sweep, found zero of nine held fragments with equivalent route cost plus frozen accepted outcomes, and advanced the cost protocol to ledger v5 without selecting a winner at that evidence cut.
A release floor is not participant exposure.
MAIDR's public code pins a legacy AI-study surface and first containing `v2.10.0` tag, while leaving the exact tested build and model unknown. Later maintenance and the TypeScript rewrite add zero representative-user rechecks.
Exact version required for lifecycle evidence.
Four public candidates yielded zero new episodes. A representative pre-AI accessibility study and a current AI-enabled rewrite remain separate until the exact release receives a representative recheck; a described-but-removed human study is not a trust result.
No benchmark-to-configuration shortcut.
Added two direct human/model chart studies and a five-threat validity audit. Task success, human-like errors, analytical intent, reader experience, and configuration value remain separate; no current Vizier configuration winner exists.
Machine totals need phase and topology.
Added adjacent ProMCP profiling plus a release audit; ledger v4 now preserves cold start, discovery, execution phase, effective topology and runtime state without claiming a visualization baseline, reproduced run, or cost winner.
Contribution is not operational handoff.
Added accepted non-owner AI-assisted changes in Prism and OpenClaw, Prism's repeat contributor, and OpenClaw's open repair proposal. These improve evidence that another person can change the artifacts; they do not establish maintenance authority, a merged repair, or independent recovery.
A repaired release is not independent recovery.
Added Prism as the third same-artifact dashboard afterlife and the first held multi-attempt delivery chain. The case reaches v1.8.11 and a maintainer runtime check, but no independent final recheck, whole cost, handoff, accessible-reader use, decision, or trust outcome.
Equal rounds are not equal resources.
Added METAL as a seventh cost fragment: its same-task quality comparison is useful, but its routes have different call topologies and lack reconciled per-arm usage. The ledger now requires both a frozen multidimensional cap and observed receipts; no route ran and no cost winner exists.
A second same-artifact afterlife.
Added OpenClaw Agent Dashboard's release-to-failure chain and independent operator report; kept accepted repair, corrected release, recheck, whole cost, handoff, accessibility, decisions, trust, and code-level AI causality explicitly open.
Governed-BI context envelope added.
Turned two bounded Fabric Community captures into a five-part pilot receipt for traversal, permissions, semantic inclusion, acceptance state, and correction/incident ownership. The sources remain C-grade self-report, not a platform verdict or demand signal.
Specialist cost now begins before inference.
Added one peer-reviewed preparation/inference fragment, quarantined its exact figures after four internal reconciliation failures, and expanded the comparison to eleven lanes, five cost classes, declared amortization, and a source- integrity preflight. No route ran and no cost winner exists.
Specialist total-cost ledger designed, not run.
Preserved five incompatible evidence fragments without summing them, then defined one same-task, equal-budget, ten-lane comparison through acceptance, delivery, readers, and maintenance. No total, route winner, or budget authorization exists.
Durable-learning test specified, not run.
Added the three-arm, five-wave longitudinal design, separate blinded reader stage, and explicit human, accessibility, power, model, budget, analysis, and release boundaries without claiming a learning or atrophy result.
Forecast record corrected without hindsight rewriting.
Added the ViviDoc typed-interaction result, classified it as pre-freeze evidence captured after freeze, and preserved all seven unresolved forecast probabilities and higher-level reader/lifecycle boundaries.
R4 editor task prepared; no editor result.
Added ten baselines, ten calibration vignettes with two swapped repeats, three response states, and fourteen adverse rejections. Editor, appointment, calibration, tie, call, contact, ranking, and result remain absent.
R4 approval path typed; all receipts pending.
Added seven attributable receipts across five gate categories, a 30-primary-call budget boundary, exact-set release, 20 admissible paths, and 16 rejected adverse states. No provider, editor, budget, release, call, contact, or result exists.
R4 response contract frozen; no model answer.
Added two lens-specific prompts, two fail-closed schemas, three honest response states, and twelve rejected adverse records. Exact models, editor calibration, budget, release, calls, contacts, rankings, and results remain absent.
R4 inputs frozen; authority still absent.
Added five hashed SVG stimuli, 19 allowlisted model-input files, five evaluator-only truth records, nine origin bindings, and adverse leakage/hash checks. No provider, editor, spend, release, call, ranking, or result exists.
R4 protocol frozen; Q8 stays open.
Added a blocked five-context, three-model, two-lens preregistration with editor, tie, budget, release, and pilot boundaries. No call, contact, ranking, or result exists.
Scoring stays typed and non-aggregate.
Added two mechanical tiers, six nonmechanical lanes, authority binding, 90 preserved synthetic not-run states, and aggregate score/pass rejection. No actual artifact, winner, human outcome, or efficacy result is claimed.
Six decisions made answerable; none inferred.
Added one fail-closed owner/provider register with 17 admissible paths, four authority roles, and a separate final release. Kept all selections, release, spend, calls, contacts, and efficacy explicitly unresolved or zero.
Authority typed; no human result inferred.
Added five fixture-specific role maps, six nonmechanical outcome lanes, 30 explicit mechanical-pilot `not-run` states, and fail-closed human-authority checks. Kept scope selection, named people, model calls, and every human verdict unrun; the preflight remains at six blockers.
One mechanism prepared; no layer selected.
Decomposed two public skill bundles into one post-artifact evidence-reconciliation candidate with one insertion, one failure target, five evaluator-only mappings, and explicit exclusions. Corrected its schema so an unresolved or discrepant checkpoint cannot report overall pass. Kept owner ratification, model calls, and efficacy unrun; the preflight remains at six blockers.
Neutral runner isolates task input from evaluator truth.
Added five deterministic source checks, 15 isolated fixture-arm envelopes, explicit model/evaluator separation, external output hashing, and fail-closed receipt identity validation; reduced the preflight from seven to six blockers while keeping zero calls and no spend authority explicit.
Added exact packet/tool/skill custody, a common receipt schema, and a seven- blocker preflight; recorded zero calls and no spend, and made the neutral artifact runner the next executable gate.
Interactive packet completes the five-of-five source gate.
Added two synthetic data versions, canonical state, ten expected states, seven replay trajectories, stale-selection recovery, exact export, history, keyboard, narrow delivery, and prepared-change contracts; kept application, accessibility, maintenance, human-outcome, and architecture claims unrun.
Specialized uncertainty packet makes four of five contexts executable.
Added exact official ACS estimate, margin-of-error, geography, comparison, refusal, branch, render, and expert-review receipts; kept the baseline, expert verdict, reader outcome, and cross-domain claim explicitly unrun.
Governed-BI packet makes three of five contexts executable.
Added a first-party synthetic semantic model, vintage, roles, verified queries, refusals, and exact fanout incident; kept production security, reliability, adoption, and human outcomes explicitly unrun.
Exploratory packet makes two of five contexts executable.
Added the exact CC0 source, pooled/within-species reversal, branch-preserving task, and familiar-data use limit; architecture comparison remains gated on the then-missing packets and equivalent receipts across every arm.
First E0 source packet.
Added the reconciled historical custody boundary and kept architecture comparison gated on missing source packets plus equivalent receipts across every arm.
Repair is a testable rung, not maintenance proof.
Added the current DV-World repair and evolution results and kept their production, people, and cost boundary explicit.
One same-artifact afterlife, not a complete lifecycle.
Added the KubeStellar production incident, repair, restored-deploy, and prevention chain plus PM4Py-UCM's measured refinement-cost fragment; kept comparison, whole cost, handoff, accessible readers, decisions, and trust open.
Readability and navigation update.
Added selective emphasis to the load-bearing conclusions and linked claims to the relevant visual experiences and deep-dive reports.
Initial public edition.
Condensed the research, practitioner, human-skills, learning, agent-skill, specialized-vision, and forecasting work into one decision-oriented summary.
Retired a repeated retrieval route without promoting an access gap.
Three bounded B91 passes now support a named-surface stop rule: the `6 / 20 / 1 / 0` content ledger is unchanged, one row is access-blocked and unassessed, zero generic B91 targets remain active, and four exact conditions can reopen it.
Mapped InfoViP research contacts without inventing operating authority.
The closed Elsa/API/UI opportunity names three research mentors but supplies no execution receipt; its nonemployee boundary cannot furnish governmental approval. An adjacent AI-QA project does not name InfoViP or a completed audit. Operation, maintenance, QA execution, release approval, authorization, and the application join remain unassigned.
Repaired InfoViP's chronology and application boundary.
A future-tense FDA page is explicitly content-current to 2024, a 2026 FDA biography names a project lead without operations authority, and the Elsa 4.0/HALO launch contains no InfoViP join. Search recency and agency-level release no longer distort the maintained episode.
Final InfoViP report adds a production component and its QA afterlife.
Added processing approval, AWS/AERS integration, >30 million historical plus ~8,000 daily submissions, bounded routine case-series use, and monitoring. Kept the absent QA plan, planned audits, incomplete roles, uninvestigated downstream effect, current no-ATO record, and all complete episodes visible. A 2026 Elsa/API/UI opportunity is prospective.
InfoViP gained counted field-use and award-envelope receipts.
Added 20 unique reviewers and 58 submissions from a six-month internal real-work evaluation, a later 29-million-history plus daily operating pipeline, and three FDA awards totaling $2.40 million obligated / $2.86 million estimated. Kept acceptance/ATO, current routine use, outcome, affected-reviewer return, whole cost, ROI, and all complete episodes absent.
InfoViP added an operational-pipeline and governance- counterevidence row.
Joined co-design, an operational pilot, 28-million- report plus incoming processing, and a later performance report while the current inventory still says development, implementation N/A, and no ATO. The exact-artifact audit is now 15 named cases and zero complete episodes.
One exact publisher abstract reduced the unassessed ledger to one.
B92 adds a bounded non-AI multicriteria, Monte Carlo, and rank-stability method at the abstract layer. B91 remains content-unassessed; the 27-row ledger is 6 full / 20 abstract or official / 1 unassessed / 0 complete AI lifecycles.
Partial source lineage kept below a deployed build.
The live DiscoverWater page differs from the sole published v1.2 page state, while eight of twelve dependency names and two of three canonical asset samples support partial shared lineage. The prototype demonstration and analytics hooks add no accepted-build, use, outcome, accessibility, cost, or AI receipt.
Final-three recovery found one public-delivery afterlife.
B110 now has an official abstract, pinned framework and application source, and a same-named DiscoverWater interface reachable at KU. At that pass B92 and B91 remained content-unassessed. The 27-row ledger was then six full texts, 19 abstract or official-content rows, and two unassessed; no exact live-build join, use denominator, audience outcome, recheck, or AI lifecycle was admitted.
Residual DOI content recovery stopped at three unknowns.
All 14 residual rows were investigated; eleven gained substantive primary content, including one full chapter, while three remain metadata-only. B102 adds an evaluation-to-redesign mechanism and B78/B38 add practice context, but no explicit GenAI role, accepted release, routine-use denominator, consequential outcome, or later affected-audience recheck.
Seven human evaluations kept below one deployed lifecycle.
Nine high-signal DOI rows yield eight primary abstract or official-project surfaces and seven explicit participant/evaluator studies. InfoViP adds one NLP and unsupervised-learning production-intent near-miss; future-tense installation remains below accepted release, routine use, outcome, and later recheck. Fourteen DOI rows still lack substantive primary content.
Non-DOI recovery repaired authority before classifying evidence.
Eight stable keys yielded three DOI recoveries, two year corrections, one rejected foreign PMID, four full texts, and one gated row. The strongest receipt is a non-AI cancer-diary embedded-use/usability comparator; zero complete AI lifecycles were added.
Human studies kept below deployment.
Primary-text recovery for A208's 27 no-abstract DOI rows puts five exact texts into custody: four empirical papers and one review. Controlled audience measurement, public- sector co-design/demo, and enterprise production intent remain three artifact-specific receipt lanes; none reaches accepted field release plus later affected-audience recheck. Twenty-two DOI rows remain unassessed.
Mature non-AI afterlife kept out of the AI lifecycle.
Exact- DOI discovery covers 114 stable keys and 87 abstracts. AIDSVu is the sole five-category lifecycle signal, adding ten years of delivery, aggregate use, governance, and a later data release—but no AI role or affected-audience recheck. The remaining abstract and identifier gaps stay unclassified.
Artifact custody separated from audience delivery.
A deterministic title-cue screen over 122 authoritative A208 keys surfaces one explicit GPT course study and one pinned 1,271-blob supplement. It yields zero audience-delivery or later-recheck chains; 121 title nonmatches remain not surfaced rather than excluded, and the lifecycle denominator stays null.
Longitudinal evaluation fills the development-decision middle, not the lifecycle.
Lexara adds six developers using a deployed CVA evaluation toolkit for two weeks across 38 experiments, 57 newly authored cases, ten models, and six prompts. The combined twelve-receipt audit covers 14 named cases and still finds zero exact artifact carried through accepted delivery, consequential audience decision or calibrated trust, whole cost, and post-release same-lineage recheck.
Full six-domain crosswalk isolates five authority gaps.
The 127 supplement positions now map to 122 distinct A208 review keys. Five exact-looking DOI candidates remain outside the review-controlled frame, one printed PMID resolves to an unrelated paper, and lifecycle classification remains unstarted and null.
First domain crosswalk finds a second authority gap.
Eleven printed Education labels plus the B59 overlay resolve to twelve distinct A208 bibliography/DOI keys. `M. Lu (2020)` has no A208 bibliography record; a plausible Crossref candidate stays outside the authoritative frame. The Education crosswalk remains 12 of 13 and lifecycle classification remains null.
Education placeholder repaired; stable-key audit still open.
A208's post-selection Education paragraph and B59 bibliography uniquely reconstruct the published `?` as Hernández-Calderón et al. (2023), DOI `10.1093/iwc/iwac043`. The gap ledger retains the broken source value, distinguishes the overlay from a publisher correction, and keeps lifecycle classification null until all rows have stable keys.
Review inventory repair placed before lifecycle screening.
A208's supplement preserves domain totals of 127 but identifies 126 citations and one literal question-mark Education row. The gap ledger now keeps count, identity, and lifecycle classification separate; no placeholder becomes a negative finding.
A review corpus is not a lifecycle denominator.
Added a 127-study decision-visualization review as a broad coverage map. Because the review does not specifically focus on GenAI and does not jointly extract the eight same-artifact receipts, the qualifying lifecycle count remains null, not zero; primary-paper classification is the next denominator-changing step.
Same endpoint, different retry burden, no cost winner.
The VisCoder2 audit reconstructs 584 versus 714 conditional revisions over 888 tasks before both routes reach 732 execution passes. Missing comparable debug-resource telemetry and human or production acceptance keep the result at attempt topology; the total-cost ledger is now v7 with 0/12 accepted-cost comparisons.
Production recovery states separated by actor.
Three held dashboard afterlives now resolve to two maintainer-verified restorations, zero affected-actor recoveries, zero authority transfers, and zero complete twelve-state rows; the gap ledger names the first valid upgrade receipt.
Reader outcomes split by AI role and lineage.
A bounded ten-row audit now separates one direct controlled AI-created-chart reader effect, five adjacent human-outcome rows, three creator/co-design rows, and one model-reader-only row. Zero reaches accepted delivery plus later same- lineage reader recheck.
Governance split into two evidence rails.
Three provider control contracts and two named-feature organizational-use reports are now shown as real but non-substitutable evidence, alongside two adjacent governance-process studies. Zero of seven held rows clears the nine-receipt same-deployment join.
Acquisition separated from adoption.
Twelve named skill listings have public install signals, but collapse to ten parent repositories and eleven documented lineages. The seven-stage public ladder now keeps listing and acquisition separate from successful presence, invocation, retention, organizational acceptance, and outcomes; 0/12 named rows reaches the latter behavioral stages in held public evidence.
Eleven-stage system anatomy added.
Six primary authoring or analysis systems all separate generation, execution, and some critique route; four expose meaningful human control; zero reaches accepted delivery, intended-reader outcome, or later maintenance. The public map assigns information and authority without selecting one universal agent topology.
The capability-to-practice bridge is short, not empty.
Ten primary cases yield three controlled partial joins—to analyst use, analyst correction, and reader harm—but zero exact-version accepted-delivery bridge and zero complete episode. The gap ledger retains the first missing receipt rather than composing a lifecycle across studies.
Fixed-budget near miss added.
Selective TTS matches declared LLM-call and separate output-token budgets inside one visual-insights pipeline, but its released accounting omits repair and errored-worker cost and its candidates are not contract-accepted artifacts. The maintenance and cost row now distinguishes declared partial budget, observed route-wide use, and accepted-output cost; the complete result is 0/11.
Six-receipt lifecycle null made explicit.
Seven leading cases were audited across repeated representative use, immutable tested build, exact model, versioned release, later event, and post-change recheck. Zero clears the full join; the null is search-scoped and retains every partial lane and reopen condition.
Longitudinal co-design added without lifecycle promotion.
Graphy follows three blind co-designers through 12 sessions, four workshops, eight months, and implemented interaction changes. Its paper disclaims formal evaluation, and its seven-commit public repository has no workshop binding, release, or representative recheck; zero new complete episodes were added.
Accepted-artifact denominator added.
ChartAgent's accuracy/tool-call sweep adds one partial cost proxy, but zero of nine held fragments has equivalent route cost plus frozen accepted outcomes. Ledger v5 retains failures in the numerator and rejects benchmark accuracy, tool calls, and per-attempt averages as accepted-cost substitutes.
Study surface found; tested build still unknown.
MAIDR's public legacy code now supplies a dedicated AI-study surface, a `v2.10.0` version floor, and real later maintenance. The abstract-level eight-person result has no exact tested-build or model join, the later changes have no representative recheck, and the TypeScript rewrite is a new validation target.
Four near-misses, zero new lifecycle episodes.
Added a seven-key horizontal admission rule, representative pre-AI MAIDR accessibility evidence, the current AI rewrite boundary, and a described-but-removed human study. Useful evidence stays in its lane; project history does not become an artifact afterlife by aggregation.
Five validity threats block configuration promotion.
Added CHART-6 and a high-level human/model interpretation study, separated task success from human-like errors and reader experience, forbade benchmark lift, and kept the qualifying current Vizier configuration-run count at zero.
Machine totals need phase and topology.
Added adjacent ProMCP profiling and a pinned release audit. The total-cost ledger now keeps cold start, discovery, execution phase, effective topology and runtime state visible; no visualization comparison, reproduced run, or cost winner was added.
Contribution is a state, not a handoff conclusion.
Added accepted non-owner AI-assisted work in Prism and OpenClaw, Prism's repeat contribution, and OpenClaw's open repair proposal. The evaluator must keep contribution, authority, and recovery separate; no complete lifecycle comparison exists.
Repaired release separated from independent recovery.
Added Prism as a third same-artifact dashboard afterlife and the first held multi-attempt delivery chain. It reaches corrected release and maintainer runtime verification, not independent final acceptance; no complete cost or lifecycle comparison exists.
Equal rounds are not equal resources.
Added METAL as the seventh specialist-cost fragment. Its routes match at five candidates or recurrences but not call topology, and the paper and released logs lack the observed per-arm usage needed for an equal-budget claim. The ledger now requires planned and observed receipts across twelve resource dimensions; no run or cost winner exists.
Total cost starts before inference.
Added a sixth fragment, quarantined its exact figures after four source-integrity failures, and expanded the protocol to eleven lanes, five cost classes, declared amortization, and a source preflight. No route ran and no winner exists.
One production afterlife, no complete lifecycle.
Added KubeStellar's self-reported same-dashboard regression, two-step repair, restored deploy, and prevention chain plus PM4Py-UCM's measured refinement effort; preserved the missing whole cost, comparison, handoff, accessible reader, decision, and trust lanes.
Total workflow cost gets a denominator, not a winner.
Audited five primary cost fragments and added a same-task, equal-budget, ten-lane ledger through accepted delivery, reader use, and a later change. The held record supports no summed total or specialist-versus-general ranking.
Longitudinal learning gap made runnable, not resolved.
Added the bounded search null and a three-arm, five-wave creator design with six-month unassisted transfer, a separate blinded reader stage, ten outcome lanes, and ten unfulfilled human/experimental release gates.
Typed interaction plan added; forecast still unchanged.
Added ViviDoc's State–Render–Transition–Constraint mechanism, same-pipeline ablation, creator/rater evidence, and reader/lifecycle limits; disclosed that it predates the forecast freeze and resolves none of the seven tests.
Editor calibration task prepared, not performed.
Added ten stimulus-by-lens baselines, ten synthetic quality vignettes with two swapped repeats, three response states, 14 rejected adverse records, and seven audience decisions. No editor, appointment, calibration, tie, call, contact, ranking, or result exists.
Seven R4 receipts defined; all real answers pending.
Added three per-slot provider receipts, editor acceptance and calibration, a capped 30-primary-call budget, exact-set release, 20 admissible paths, 16 rejected adverse states, and seven audience decisions. No provider, editor, budget, release, call, contact, ranking, or result exists.
Two R4 prompts, two schemas, zero model answers.
Added separate integrity and readability prompts, three honest raw-response states, twelve rejected aggregate/lens/identity/evidence/state failures, and seven audience decisions. Exact models, editor calibration, budget, release, calls, contacts, rankings, and results remain absent.
Five R4 inputs frozen; no model run.
Added five opaque-ID SVGs, a 19-file model-input allowlist, nine source-evidence files, five evaluator-only truth records, adverse leakage/hash checks, corrected visual-inspection findings, and seven audience decisions. Model slots, editor, tie, prompts, budget, release, calls, and results remain absent.
R4 is preregistered, not run.
Added five candidate contexts, three empty exact-model slots, separate integrity/readability lenses, a human-editor and tie-rule gate, seven audience translations, and a pilot boundary. No stimulus, ranking, call, contact, or divergence exists.
Outcomes stay separated instead of becoming one score.
Added two mechanical tiers, six exact nonmechanical lanes, authority binding, 90 preserved synthetic `not-run` states, aggregate-score rejection, and seven audience translations. No artifact, arm winner, human result, or efficacy claim is implied.
Six gates become an attributable decision register.
Added 17 admissible paths across four authority roles, fail-closed response and final-release rules, and seven audience translations. All six selections and release remain pending; no provider fact, approval, spend, contact, call, or efficacy result is implied.
Acceptance authority stays typed and human.
Added six nonmechanical authority lanes, five fixture-specific role maps, a 30-state mechanical-only `not-run` policy, W3C's conformance/user-evaluation boundary, seven audience decisions, and the research-owner gate. No person, model call, human verdict, or scope selection is implied.
One-layer candidate separates mechanism from skill bundle.
Added one post-artifact evidence-reconciliation candidate, its five-part causal-unit test, five-context failure target, seven audience decisions, and the owner-ratification boundary. No selection, call, or effect is claimed.
Credential-free runner separates task from evaluator.
Added five source checks, 15 isolated fixture-arm envelopes, an explicit model- input/evaluator-only boundary, external artifact/render/trace/check hashing, fail-closed receipt identity, six residual blockers, and seven audience translations. No model, artifact, browser, human, or efficacy result is implied.
Current-harness manifest preflight.
Added the exact fields that can be frozen before a call, an 18-field equivalent-receipt contract, seven named blockers, zero-call/no-spend evidence, and audience-specific rules for interpreting a workflow comparison.
Interactive-application source packet.
Added the fifth of five E0 source packets, including exact canonical state, synchronized surfaces, replay, history, reset, export, keyboard, narrow delivery, stale-selection recovery, and prepared-change gates with explicit browser, maintenance, accessibility, and human-evidence limits.
Specialized uncertainty source packet.
Added the fourth of five E0 source packets, including exact official estimate, margin-of-error, geography, pairwise-test, misleading-rank, refusal, render, and expert-review gates with explicit cross-domain and human-evidence limits.
Governed-BI source packet.
Added the third of five E0 source packets, including exact semantic, vintage, permission, verified-query, refusal, fanout, and incident-recovery gates with explicit production and human-evidence limits.
Exploratory source packet.
Added the second of five E0 source packets, including exact pooled/group checks, revision receipts, audience-specific use boundaries, and an explicit familiar-data limit.
Shared-baseline readiness gate.
Added the reconciled historical custody boundary, the initial context-readiness state, and the equivalent-receipt requirement for bare, normal-harness, and one-layer arms.
Initial public edition.
Established the contextual goals typology, literature synthesis, technique history, benchmark timeline, convergence and divergence findings, demonstrated negatives, and research gap ledger.
Retired repeated B91 retrieval without classifying the paper.
Three bounded lawful passes exhausted the same named surfaces, so generic search is paused with four exact reopen conditions. The content ledger remains `6 / 20 / 1 / 0`; one access-blocked row remains unassessed, zero generic B91 targets remain active, and effort moves to a stronger lifecycle-bearing target unless exact new custody appears.
Added the InfoViP actor and closed-opportunity afterlife.
Three current research mentors now have bounded role coordinates; the closed listing, nonemployee fellowship contract, and adjacent QA project still establish zero named operating or approval authorities and no shipped InfoViP–Elsa integration.
Repaired the InfoViP episode chain instead of accepting search recency.
The future-tense FDA page is content-current to 2024, not 2026. A current FDA biography names a project lead without establishing operations or maintenance authority, and the Elsa 4.0/HALO launch does not name InfoViP. The maintained chain remains 15 named cases and zero complete episodes.
The final InfoViP report adds component approval and production integration, plus explicit QA limits.
It reports AWS/AERS integration, more than 30 million historical and about 8,000 daily submissions, fully implemented case-series use, and administrator monitoring. It also says the QA plan is absent, audits are planned, routine roles are incomplete, and signal-discovery effects are uninvestigated. A 2026 Elsa/API/UI opportunity is a prospective change trigger; 15 named cases still yield zero complete episodes.
InfoViP added counted real-work use, operating scale, and a bounded award envelope.
A six-month internal evaluation records 20 unique reviewers and 58 submissions; a 2025 primary abstract reports operation over 29 million historic plus daily incoming reports; three FDA awards total $2.40 million obligated and $2.86 million estimated. Current routine use, whole-platform acceptance/ATO, outcome, affected-reviewer return, and whole cost remain absent; the audit stays at 15 named and zero complete episodes.
InfoViP crossed into an operational pipeline, not a complete lifecycle.
Joined seven-evaluator co-design to an agency-reported pilot, 28-million-report plus incoming-report processing, a later performance and human-quality-control report, and current development/no-ATO counterevidence. The combined audit is now 15 named cases and zero complete episodes.
One publisher abstract closed one content gap, not a lifecycle.
B92 now contributes a multicriteria, Monte Carlo, rank-stability decision-support method at the exact publisher-abstract layer. B91 remains content-unassessed; the current ledger is six full texts, 20 abstract or official-content rows, one unassessed row, and zero complete AI lifecycles.
Live source lineage tested rather than assumed.
The current DiscoverWater page does not match the sole published page state. Two of three sampled data assets match canonically, but no exact build, audience-use, outcome, accessibility, cost, or AI receipt was recovered.
One public-delivery afterlife kept below use and impact.
B110 gained an official abstract, pinned framework and application source, and a same-named DiscoverWater interface reachable at KU. The residual is now B92 and B91; no live-build join, continuous or ordinary-use denominator, audience outcome, recheck, whole cost, or AI role was admitted.
The residual primary-content gap reduced to three.
All 14 remaining DOI rows were investigated; eleven gained substantive content, including one full chapter, while three remain metadata-only. One expert evaluation-to-redesign mechanism and two practice-context near misses were added without promoting any row into a GenAI role, accepted release, routine-use denominator, consequential outcome, or later recheck.
Seven human evaluations kept below one deployed lifecycle.
Eight new primary abstract or official-project surfaces add seven explicit participant/evaluator studies. InfoViP is the strongest delivery near-miss, but its NLP and unsupervised-learning production installation is prospective; 14 DOI rows remain content-unassessed and zero complete lifecycles are added.
Field use kept below AI lifecycle.
Repaired three DOIs, two publication years, and one foreign PMID across eight stable keys; added the cancer diary's increasing-use and 11-clinician usability receipts while retaining its missing AI role, accepted build, outcome, later event, and affected-clinician recheck.
Human evidence separated into three pre-deployment lanes.
Five exact full texts entered custody below A208's 27 no-abstract DOI rows. Four empirical papers add controlled audience measurement, public-sector co-design/demo/bounded use, and enterprise demonstrator/production-intent receipts; none joins accepted field release to later affected-audience recheck. Twenty-two DOI rows and eight non-DOI keys remain unassessed.
Mature visualization afterlife kept outside the AI denominator.
Exact-DOI discovery covers 114 stable keys and 87 available abstracts, adding no hidden GenAI signal. AIDSVu contributes ten years of public delivery, aggregate use, governance, and a later 2026 data release, but no AI role, immutable build, version-bound audience outcome, or affected- audience recheck. Eighty-six abstract nonmatches remain unexcluded.
One pinned output bundle kept below audience evidence.
A bounded screen of A208's 122 authoritative stable-key titles surfaced one explicit GPT study. Its one-commit supplement preserves 1,271 blobs across quizzes and homework, but exposes no immutable provider snapshot, named release, later commit, audience delivery, audience outcome, or recheck. The other 121 title nonmatches remain unscreened rather than negative.
Longitudinal development decision kept below audience consequence.
Added Lexara's two-week deployment with six CVA developers, 38 experiments, 57 newly authored cases, ten models, and six prompts. The combined audit now covers 14 named reader, production, and evaluation cases; zero joins all twelve receipts from immutable build through accepted delivery, consequential decision or calibrated trust, and post-release recheck.
Complete review register keeps five candidates outside the denominator.
The six domains contribute 127 supplement positions and 122 distinct A208 review keys. Five exact-looking DOI identities lack review- controlled joins, one printed PMID points elsewhere, and screening remains unstarted rather than producing a false zero.
Education crosswalk stops at 12 of 13 authoritative keys.
Eleven printed labels plus B59 resolve to A208 bibliography/DOI keys. `M. Lu (2020)` is supplement-only relative to A208; a plausible Crossref paper is retained as a candidate, not silently admitted. The public account now separates source label, review key, candidate, and admission authority.
Missing Education name reconstructed without rewriting the source.
A208's post-selection Education paragraph leaves B59, Hernández-Calderón et al. (2023), as the unique example absent from the twelve named supplement entries; its bibliography and Crossref agree on DOI `10.1093/iwc/iwac043`. The public account now carries `published: ?` beside the repair overlay while keeping the full stable-key crosswalk and lifecycle count unfinished.
Review inventory found count-complete but identity- incomplete.
The publisher supplement's six domain totals sum to 127, but its “full list” names 126 citations and leaves one Education entry as a literal question mark. Repair now precedes any complete row-level screen; the reported total stays 127 and the lifecycle count stays unknown.
Review breadth separated from lifecycle denominator.
Added a 127-study decision-visualization review as a coverage map, retained its explicit non-GenAI and longitudinal limits, and kept the qualifying same-artifact lifecycle count unknown rather than reporting zero of 127.
Production recovery split into twelve states.
Consolidated three dashboard afterlives into an actor-separated ledger: two reach accepted repair, corrected delivery, and maintainer recheck; zero reaches affected- actor recheck, authority transfer, or all twelve states.
Reader-outcome delivery boundary.
Added an eight-receipt lineage test across ten primary rows. ChartAttack supplies the sole direct controlled AI-created-chart reader effect; zero row reaches accepted delivery, representative intended-context outcome, and later recheck.
Product controls separated from governed deployment.
A seven-row governance audit now keeps three provider control contracts, two named-feature organizational-use stories, and two adjacent longitudinal governance processes distinct. Zero row carries the nine-receipt same-deployment chain; the gap is bounded to the held public surfaces.
Three controlled bridges, zero accepted-delivery bridges.
Audited ten primary cases across technical evidence, human use or correction, acceptance, delivery, reader outcome, maintenance, and whole cost. HAIChart, interactive task decomposition, and ChartAttack form three bounded partial bridges; none reaches exact-version accepted delivery or a complete episode.
A fixed inference budget is not accepted-work cost.
Added Selective TTS as the strongest held matched-budget near miss. Its declared calls and separate output-token budgets are close, but released accounting omits repair and failed-worker cost and its “final reports” are candidates. Practitioners now get three receipts—declared, observed, accepted—and the complete result is 0/11.
Six receipts, seven cases, zero full chains.
Audited Graphy, MAIDR-AI, Prism, OpenClaw, KubeStellar, PM4Py-UCM, and DV-World against one exact release-validation join. Every receipt appears somewhere; no row joins all six, and the result remains scoped to named surfaces rather than the world.
Repeated co-design separated from release afterlife.
Added Graphy's three returning blind co-designers, 12 sessions, four workshops, eight-month span, implemented interaction changes, seven public commits, and explicit formal-evaluation limit. No workshop-version binding, release, later representative recheck, or complete lifecycle episode was added.
Accepted cost separated from attempt averages.
Added the two-receipt rule for practitioner productivity: keep every attempt and failure in route cost, count only contract-passing artifacts, and report the then-current 0/9 held-comparison result without inferring a winner.
Version floor is not the tested version.
Pinned MAIDR's later AI study to a dedicated legacy study surface and `v2.10.0` as the first containing tag. The abstract reports eight blind and low-vision participants; the tested build, model snapshot, detailed results, and any representative recheck after nine selected maintenance and deprecation events remain missing.
A project history is not a same-artifact afterlife.
Audited four promising horizontal joins and admitted zero new episodes. Added representative pre-AI MAIDR accessibility evidence, retained the current AI-enabled rewrite as a separate artifact state, quarantined a described-but- removed public-health human study, and exposed the seven-key join for each intended audience.
Accepted contribution is not maintenance handoff.
Added Prism's external visual contribution through review, repair, release, and a later accepted return; OpenClaw's accepted external pricing work; and its separate open repair proposal. Keep contribution, authority, and recovery as different receipts.
Repaired release is not independent recovery.
Added Prism as the third same-artifact dashboard afterlife and the first held multi-attempt delivery chain. It reaches v1.8.11 and a maintainer install/start/restart check; the affected operator's final recheck and the rest of the complete lifecycle remain missing.
A second dashboard afterlife, observed from outside the project.
Added OpenClaw Agent Dashboard's release-to-failure chain: one non-owner operator reported a misleading zero cost display, commit-pinned code supports the mechanism, and the owner acknowledged an untested configuration. Added a six-field admission card and kept repair, corrected release, recheck, whole cost, handoff, accessibility, decisions, trust, and AI causality open.
One same-artifact production afterlife.
Added the KubeStellar Console incident chain from AI-assisted change through live regression, two-step repair, restored deployment, and a new prevention check; added PM4Py-UCM's measured refinement-cost fragment; translated the result for six audience routes; and kept whole cost, handoff, accessible reader use, consequential decisions, calibrated trust, comparison, and transfer explicitly open.
Maintenance-shaped benchmark evidence.
Added DV-World's 50 native Excel repair tasks and 80 visualization-evolution tasks, audited the released evaluators, translated prepared change tests for six audience routes, and preserved the boundary between one benchmark episode and a real artifact's afterlife.
Lifecycle evidence and audience decision layer.
Added a four-year HealthTech governance-visualization program, preserved why it is adjacent rather than generative-authoring evidence, and introduced a shared lifecycle acceptance ledger translated for practitioners, leaders, editors, researchers, product teams, and accessibility work.
Initial public edition.
Mapped practitioner jobs and tool choices, synthesized creator and reader accounts, and separated possible output, accomplished work, delivery, and lived outcome.
Added accepted external AI-assisted work in Prism and OpenClaw, Prism's repeat contributor, and OpenClaw's open repair proposal. None supplies a named second maintainer or independent recovery, so production efficiency, governance, and maintenance stays 1 / 4.
Third afterlife case; lifecycle score unchanged.
Added Prism's multi-attempt Home Assistant delivery chain through v1.8.11 and a maintainer runtime check. Independent final acceptance, comparison, whole cost, handoff, and reader outcomes remain missing, so production efficiency, governance, and maintenance stays 1 / 4.
Second afterlife case; lifecycle score unchanged.
Added OpenClaw Agent Dashboard's non-owner operator-reported cost-display failure. The case improves observer diversity but stops before accepted repair, corrected release, recheck, whole cost, handoff, or reader outcomes, so production efficiency, governance, and maintenance remains 1 / 4.
One afterlife case; lifecycle score unchanged.
Added KubeStellar's self-reported same-dashboard production incident and repair chain plus PM4Py-UCM's measured refinement record. Neither supplies the comparison, whole cost, handoff, or reader outcomes required to move production efficiency, governance, and maintenance above 1 / 4.
First calibration check; scores and forecasts unchanged.
Added ViviDoc as a typed-interaction mechanism and visible pre-freeze source omission while preserving every score, probability, confidence value, and higher-level outcome boundary.
Initial public edition.
Defined the ideal-state dimensions, fixed maturity rubric, August 2026 field assessment, historical reconstruction, contextual endpoints, and forecast score movements.
Added two direct human/model comparisons and a five-threat promotion preflight. CHART-6's common-task errors and a high-level interpretation study separate task success, human-like behavior, analytical intent, and reader experience; the current Vizier configuration-run count remains zero.
Initial public edition.
Crosswalked generation, execution, semantic, perceptual, integrity, interaction, and human-outcome evaluations to their supported claims and important nonclaims.
Collapsed twelve counted listings to ten parent repositories and eleven documented lineages; inspected the official CLI's selected-skill install event and missing invocation/outcome telemetry; and added a seven-stage evidence ladder. The bounded result is 12/12 install signals and 0/12 observed invocation, retention, organizational acceptance, or outcome rows.
Paired D3 task and audience translations.
Added SkillLearnBench's no-skill, human-authored, and generated-skill comparison; audited its rendered-behavior verifier; and kept named-package, reader, accessibility, and maintenance outcomes open.
Initial public edition.
Cataloged agent skill packages, adoption signals, recurring techniques, evaluation evidence, likely failure modes, and an ordered ablation program.
Recomputed VisCoder2 and GPT-4.1 self-debug paths over 888 tasks: both finish at 732 execution passes, while the routes use 584 versus 714 revisions. The released debug paths do not retain comparable resource telemetry, and execution is not human or production acceptance. Ledger v7 therefore advances to twelve held fragments, 0/12 accepted-cost comparisons, and no route winner.
Matched inference budget separated from total accepted cost.
Added the Selective TTS visual-insights paper and commit-pinned code audit, plus DV-World's same-harness interaction-charge view. One of eleven held fragments now matches a declared partial call/output-token budget; zero has equivalent observed route-wide use plus frozen accepted outcomes. Ledger v6 keeps those receipt levels separate and selects no winner.
Accepted-artifact denominator made explicit.
Added ChartAgent's same-task accuracy/tool-call sweeps as a partial cost proxy, found zero of nine held fragments with both equivalent route cost and a frozen accepted-artifact denominator, and advanced the ledger to v5. No route ran and no cost winner exists.
Machine totals split by phase and topology.
Added adjacent ProMCP evidence and a commit-pinned release audit. Ledger v4 now preserves cold start, discovery, execution phase, effective topology and runtime state; the source does not add a visualization comparison, reproduced run, or cost winner.
Equal rounds separated from equal resources.
Added METAL's same-task chart-reconstruction result, audited its paper and official code, and found that matched `n = 5` rows do not match calls or retain observed usage. Ledger v3 now requires planned and observed receipts over twelve resource dimensions. No route ran and no cost winner exists.
Cost starts before inference; source numbers must reconcile.
Added one peer-reviewed preparation/inference fragment, quarantined its exact figures after denominator, percentage, table-delta, and configuration conflicts, and expanded the protocol to eleven lanes, five cost classes, and a source-integrity preflight. No route ran and no winner exists.
Total-cost comparison made measurable, not measured.
Audited five primary evidence fragments, exposed inference, latency, correction, evaluation, and unresolved-failure units, and added a ten-lane equal-budget ledger with explicit missingness. No route ran and no total or winner exists.
Initial public edition.
Compared six specialist vision roles, recent models and benchmarks, same-test gains, transfer failures, critic authority, and routing experiments.
Longitudinal learning study made testable, not performed.
Added the three-arm, five-wave creator protocol, separate blinded reader stage, capability/accessibility profiles, ten outcome lanes, and explicit human, ethics, power, model, budget, analysis, and release gates.
Initial public edition.
Defined the human capability profile, separated seven kinds of banked gain, and assessed which gains are observed for novices, intermediate practitioners, and experts.
Replaced a broad study wish with three arms, five creator waves through six-month unassisted transfer, a separate blinded reader stage, ten outcome lanes, and ten unfulfilled release gates. No owner, approval, participant, or result is claimed.
Initial public edition.
Assessed what AI makes easier to learn, which productive difficulties still matter, how practice should be reallocated, and which transfer evidence remains missing.
Preserved all seven frozen estimates, disclosed ViviDoc as pre-freeze evidence captured after the freeze, and separated its typed-interaction authoring result from unmeasured reader, delivery, maintenance, and autonomy outcomes.
Initial public edition.
Converted remaining capability gaps into measurable gates, separated model-driven from technique-driven gains, and recorded dated forecasts, signposts, falsifiers, and score movements.
Translated B91's access stop without changing its content state.
Every route now carries the unchanged `6 / 20 / 1 / 0` content ledger beside one access-blocked and unassessed row, zero active generic B91 targets, and four exact reopen conditions. Research effort moves only when new custody appears; paused never becomes negative.
Translated InfoViP's actor map and closed opportunity across seven routes.
Readers can now route research questions to three named mentors while preserving zero named service-operation, maintenance, QA-execution, release-approval, or authorization roles. Closed remains separate from selected, started, built, approved, and released.
Repaired one InfoViP date and role chain across seven routes.
Every route now treats the apparent 2026 future-tense page as content-current to 2024, the 2026 project-lead biography as a precise role rather than operations authority, and the Elsa 4.0/HALO launch as separate from an unobserved InfoViP-specific integration.
InfoViP's production-component and QA answer translated seven ways.
Every route now carries the final report's approval, AWS/AERS integration, >30-million-history and ~8,000-daily receipts beside its absent QA plan, planned audits, incomplete routine roles, and uninvestigated downstream effect. The current no-ATO inventory remains visible, and a 2026 Elsa/API/UI opportunity is treated only as a future recheck trigger.
InfoViP field-use, cost, and governance evidence translated seven ways.
Every route starts from 20 unique real-work evaluators, a later 29-million-history plus daily operating pipeline, and a $2.40 million obligated / $2.86 million estimated three-award envelope. Every route keeps current routine use, acceptance/ATO, outcome, return, whole cost, and ROI unresolved; 15 named cases still yield zero complete episodes.
InfoViP operational-governance result translated seven ways.
Added one canonical line from practitioner co-design through an operational pilot, at-scale incoming processing, performance and human control, and current development/no-ATO counterevidence. The audit is now 15 named cases and zero complete episodes.
One publisher-abstract answer translated seven ways.
Every route starts from B92's exact multicriteria, Monte Carlo, rank-stability abstract and the current `6 / 20 / 1 / 0` ledger. B91 remains unassessed; no route promotes a non-AI method into human use, delivery, outcome, or impact.
One partial-lineage answer translated seven ways.
Every route starts from one live page, zero exact public builds, eight of twelve matching dependency names, two of three canonical asset matches, and zero audience outcomes. No route promotes a source link, demonstration, instrumentation, or intended audience into deployment or use.
One public-delivery afterlife translated seven ways.
Every route starts from B110's official abstract, pinned source artifacts, and one current same-named live interface while preserving B92 and B91 as content-unassessed at that pass. No route promotes reachability into continuous use, source custody into the deployed build, or intended audience into measured outcome.
One residual-recovery answer translated seven ways.
Every route starts from 14 investigated rows, 11 substantive surfaces, one full chapter, three metadata-only rows, one evaluation-to-redesign mechanism, two practice-context near misses, and zero complete AI lifecycles. No route promotes expert evaluation, stakeholder application, or multi-unit evaluation into deployment or outcome.
One prototype-evaluation answer translated seven ways.
Every route starts from nine investigated rows, eight substantive surfaces, seven explicit human evaluations, InfoViP's prospective production intent, and 14 remaining content-unassessed DOI rows. No route turns future tense into deployment, conventional NLP into GenAI, or evaluation into outcome.
One field-use result translated seven ways.
Every route starts from the same eight-key authority repair and non-AI cancer-diary comparator while keeping one gated primary text, missing lifecycle receipts, and the unknown complete-review denominator visible.
One primary-evidence ladder translated seven ways.
Five recovered full texts add controlled audience measurement, public-sector co- design/demo, and enterprise production-intent lanes, but no accepted field release plus later affected-audience recheck. Every route preserves 22 DOI rows and eight non-DOI stable keys as unassessed.
One mature platform result translated without borrowing an AI role.
Seven routes now keep AIDSVu's ten-year delivery, aggregate use, governance, and later data release while retaining its missing AI role, version-bound audience outcome, and affected-audience recheck. Eighty-six abstract cue nonmatches remain unexcluded.
One custody answer translated without inventing audience evidence.
Seven routes now begin from the same bounded result: 122 titles triaged, one explicit GPT signal, one pinned supplemental-output bundle, and zero audience-delivery or later-recheck chains. The 121 title nonmatches remain not surfaced rather than excluded.
Practice gets an evaluation-to-acceptance card; BI gets a release-linked decision ledger; research gets the twelve-receipt matrix; newsrooms get a publication gate; builders get a drift-aware release export; learning and access keep outcomes separate; sponsors get one near-miss and zero complete episodes across 14 named cases. No route promotes development selection or reported confidence into audience impact.
Full 122-of-127 review frame translated across seven routes.
Every route gets the same five unresolved authority joins and one quarantined identifier conflict. The useful layer changes by audience; candidate identity, review provenance, unstarted screening, and the null lifecycle count do not.
One 12-of-13 Education result translated across seven routes.
Every route now distinguishes an authoritative review key from a plausible external candidate. `M. Lu (2020)` stays unresolved until A208- controlled evidence joins it; no audience may promote confidence into provenance or a lifecycle count.
One repair overlay translated seven ways.
Every route now receives the same source-preserving result: the supplement still prints `?`, while A208's article and DOI metadata uniquely reconstruct Hernández- Calderón et al. (2023). The decision language changes by audience; the absent publisher correction, unfinished stable-key crosswalk, and unknown lifecycle count do not.
Review inventory integrity translated seven ways.
Every route now receives the same three-state answer: 127 studies reported, 126 appendix citations identified, and the complete GenAI lifecycle count unknown. Audience language changes the decision gate without guessing the missing Education row or turning it into a negative result.
Review-lineage boundary translated seven ways.
Every route begins with the same 127-study coverage map and unknown qualifying lifecycle count, then asks for its own artifact, pilot, study, publication, instrumentation, access, or funding receipt. No translation reports zero of 127 or treats review breadth as field efficacy.
Conditional retry burden translated seven ways.
Every route begins with the same 732-of-888 endpoint and 584-versus-714 revision record, then asks for its own stopping, telemetry, acceptance, or reader receipt. No translation turns fewer generations into lower total cost or audience use.
Production recovery translated seven ways.
Every audience route begins with the same 3-afterlife, 2-restoration, 0-affected-actor- recovery, 0-authority-transfer result, then receives its own decision question without turning issue closure or contribution into recovery.
Reader-outcome boundary translated seven ways.
Each audience route keeps the same one-direct, five-adjacent, zero-delivery/recheck result while changing the decision question; no route upgrades participation, creator interpretation, or model QA into delivered audience evidence.
Governance boundary translated seven ways.
Practice, BI, research, journalism, product, learning/access, and sponsor routes now begin with the same 3-control-contract, 2-organizational-use, 2-adjacent-process, 0-complete result and ask for the first missing same-deployment receipt.
Public acquisition translated seven ways.
Practice, BI, research, journalism, product, learning/access, and sponsor routes now begin with one provenance-aware result: 12/12 named listings have install signals, while 0/12 exposes invocation, retention, organizational acceptance, or outcome. No route turns registry or repository attention into adoption.
System anatomy translated seven ways.
Practice, BI, research, journalism, product, learning/access, and sponsor routes now enter one eleven-stage information-and-authority map. The canonical result remains 6/6 generation-execution-critique, 4/6 meaningful human control, and 0/6 accepted-delivery, intended-reader, or maintenance chains; no route turns it into an architecture winner or observed audience demand.
Ten primary cases yield three controlled partial bridges and zero exact-version accepted-delivery or complete episodes. Practice, BI, research, journalism, product, learning/access, and sponsor layers now ask for the first missing receipt without changing the canonical result or implying audience use.
Fixed-budget result translated seven ways.
Selective TTS adds one matched declared partial call/output-token budget without supplying observed route-wide use or contract acceptance. Practice, BI, research, journalism, product, learning/access, and sponsor routes now keep the three receipt levels separate. The accepted-cost result advances to 0/11 and no route winner is implied.
Six-receipt null translated seven ways.
Practice, BI, research, journalism, product, learning/access, and sponsor routes now use one exact release-validation card. The answer stays zero of seven in named surfaces; every layer retains the first missing receipt and the return-user reopen condition.
Longitudinal co-design result translated seven ways.
Graphy adds three returning blind co-designers, 12 sessions, four workshops, eight months, and implemented changes. Every audience layer keeps formal efficacy, workshop-version binding, release, representative recheck, adoption, and whole cost visibly missing.
Accepted-cost result translated seven ways.
Practice, BI, research, journalism, product, learning/access, and sponsor layers now ask for one route-wide numerator and one frozen accepted-output denominator. At that evidence cut, zero of nine held fragments supplied both; no route winner was implied.
Version-floor boundary translated seven ways.
Added the distinction among study surface, first containing release, participant-tested build, later maintenance, representative recheck, and rewrite. MAIDR narrows the target but still contributes zero complete lifecycle episodes.
One lifecycle result translated seven ways.
Added the exact artifact-version join, four rejected near-misses, and a decision layer for practice, BI, research, journalism, product, learning/access, and sponsors. Every route keeps the same result: zero new episodes, a strong pre-AI accessibility baseline, and no cross-version human-evidence transfer.
One validity result translated seven ways.
Added a shared five-threat configuration boundary and audience-specific questions for practice, BI, research, journalism, product, learning/access, and sponsors. Every route keeps the same result: benchmark success is lane-bound and no current Vizier configuration winner exists.
Phase and topology language added.
Practitioner, BI, research, and builder layers now translate the same receipt: cold start, discovery, execution phase, effective topology and runtime state stay beside planned and observed totals; hidden work remains missing.
Handoff now has four audience-facing states.
The practitioner, BI, research, newsroom, product, education/access, and executive layers now distinguish accepted change, repeat contribution, maintenance authority, and independent recovery. Prism reaches the first two; OpenClaw reaches the first and has an open repair proposal. Neither reaches the last two.
Recovery now has five actor-separated receipts.
Prism's multi-attempt Home Assistant chain turns report, repair, corrected release, maintainer recheck, and independent recheck into a practitioner, BI, research, newsroom, product, and access decision rule. The last receipt is missing in the case, so the route is not called independently recovered.
Planned and observed resource receipts.
The practitioner, BI, research, and product routes now ask whether each arm stayed inside a frozen multidimensional cap and retain what each task actually used. Matching rounds, candidates, rates, nominal caps, or model labels no longer counts as equal budget; no comparison ran and no cost winner exists.
Fabric context envelope and correction receipt.
Recovered the formerly gated practitioner issue through a first-party RSS representation and added a Microsoft-authored implementation account. The BI route now asks what the assistant can traverse, under which permissions, which semantic objects it can use, and whether a wrong answer can be reproduced, corrected, regression-tested, and owned. Both sources are C-grade self-report; they do not establish a bug, breach, efficacy, prevalence, demand, or reader use.
Total-cost decision products expanded.
The practitioner clock now begins at route preparation, while the BI procurement route keeps five cost classes separate, declares volume and amortization, and rejects source telemetry whose denominator does not reconcile. This is a decision aid, not evidence that either route is cheaper.
Retained-human-value check.
Added independent newsletter, practitioner, and Portuguese teaching evidence for purpose, collaboration, creative friction, audience context, inspectable correction, feedback, and delivery. These are candidate evaluation values, not demand or effect estimates.
Audience-language evidence ladder.
Added primary custody for an independent podcast, a Spanish public-data implementation, AccessViz community outcomes, and official search-measurement limits. Separated source wording, qualified discovery, decision-path use, and changed work; expanded the accessibility route around co-creation, verification, agency, and sustained use. At that pass, Power BI/Fabric community wording remained a capture gap; the later first-party RSS pass above closes only that custody condition.
Initial public edition.
Defined audience routes, decision products, evidence boundaries, publication gates, and an outcome-oriented rollout sequence.
Three held dashboard afterlives yield two maintainer-verified restorations, zero affected-actor recoveries, zero authority transfers, and zero complete twelve-state rows. Issue closure, maintainer recheck, contribution, and authority now remain separate in the editorial bridge.
Reader-outcome bridge specified.
The missing-evidence ledger now separates one direct controlled AI-created-chart reader effect, five adjacent human-outcome rows, three creator/co-design rows, and one model- reader-only row; zero reaches the eight-receipt delivered-reader recheck chain.
Governance bridge specified.
The missing-evidence ledger now separates three provider control contracts, two named-feature organizational- use reports, and two adjacent governance processes; zero of seven held rows clears the nine-receipt same-deployment join.
Adoption bridge now has a measurement boundary.
Twelve named skill listings collapse to ten parent repositories and eleven documented lineages. The package now says public acquisition signal for the 12/12 listing rows and keeps invocation, retention, organizational acceptance, and outcome at 0/12 observed. Prevalence remains unknown and requires a privacy-respecting cohort rather than a listing sum.
Initial public edition.
Defined the comprehensive report and non-linear essay renderings, content ownership, shared evidence spine, complete table of contents, and underbuilt bridges.